NITRIFYING
AND PATHOGENIC BACTERIAL FLUCTUATION DURING NITROGEN REMOVAL FROM WASTEWATER IN
ZAKHO CITY/IRAQ
Khawla Ali Mohammed a, Mustafa Ismail Umer b,
Yasir M. Alyazichi c
a Faculty of Science, Environmental Department,
University of Zakho, Duhok, Iraq.
b Department of Soil and Water, College of
Agriculture, Duhok University, Duhok, Iraq.
c GeoQuEST Research
Centre, School of Earth, Atmospheric and Life Sciences, Faculty of Science,
Medicine and Health University of Wollongong, NSW 2522 Australia
(khawlaali096@gmail.com)
(mustafa.umer@uod.ac)
Received: 6 Nov., 2022 / Accepted: 3
Jan.., 2023 / Published: 22 May, 2023 https://doi.org/10.25271/sjuoz.2023.11.2.1058
ABSTRACT:
The high concentration of
nitrogen (N) compounds in wastewater was found to be creating a reason of
eutrophication, effect the biodiversity of aquatic ecosystems and human health.
The aim of this study is to reduce harmful N forms from wastewater by biological
nitrogen transforming (BNT) bacteria and to investigate the fluctuation of ammonium oxidizing bacteria
(AOB), nitrite oxidizing bacteria (NOB), and pathogenic bacteria during this process, so compost representative. A sample of municipal wastewater was
taken, and then subjected to the treatment process of BNT, which was subdivided
into three stages of ammonification, nitrification, and denitrification. The result
revealed that nitrifying bacteria were flocculated during biological nitrogen transformation,
like AOB and NOB isolated until obtaining colonies during the nitrification
process, by liquid mineral solution and Agar-Agar then calculated. The AOB
count was 468 CFU/ml and NOB was 2130 CFU/ml in the sample. The existence of
coliform bacteria, especially E. coli raises the possibility of water contamination
by pathogens bacteria that cause many serious illnesses in human. Therefore, Mac-Conkey agar was used for the isolation of total coliform
bacteria through the BNT process because it is selective and also
differentiating agar that specialized in the growth of gram- negative bacteria.
Total coliform bacteria decreased gradually, before ammonification (556
CFU/ml), after ammonification (226 CFU/ml), after nitrification (154 CFU/ml)
and after denitrification (45 CFU/ml) that have been determined and indicated
that further chemical disinfection like chlorination or ozonation were required
for complete sterilization of pathogenic bacteria. The study concluded that all
harmful forms of N and total coliform bacteria that cause human and ecosystem deleterious
were reduced by BNT.
Keywords: Biological nitrogen transformation BNT, AOB, NOB and Coliform
Bacteria.
1.
INTRODUCTION
Wastewater refers to water that has
undergone physical, chemical, and biological changes as a result of the
incorporation of certain substances, making it unfit for drinking or even other
uses (Amoatey & Bani, 2011). Daily activities depends primarily on water to survive and therefore
discharge waste into water (Crini &
Lichtfouse, 2019). All
liquid waste or sewage that originates from homes, hospitals, factories, or any
other building using water through its facilities is referred to as wastewater.
It is an unwanted byproduct of using water. The general composition of
wastewater can include toxic chemicals, salts, oil/grease, heavy metals,
solids, nutrients, acid/base and organic plus inorganic materials (Templeton &
Butler, 2011).
The breakdown of organic wastes by
bacteria, nematodes, or even other microscopic organisms using regular cellular
processes is the foundation of biological treatments (Wang et al., 2022). Garbage, waste, and even partially digested food are
just a few of the organic materials that are frequently found in wastewater. In
addition, it might have poisons, heavy metals, and infectious organisms (Mittal, 2011).
The nitrogen N
cycle includes the process of ammonification, which gives organisms the vital N
they require to exist. Strock (2008) showed that Ammonification is indeed the process through which
microscopic organisms, such as bacteria or even other sorts of decaying
creatures, convert compounds containing nitrogen through dead organic matter
into simple molecules such as ammonia. So, these tiny creatures support the whole
ecosystem. Ammonification, to put it more simply, is just the process of
turning naturally occurring nitrogen compounds into ammonia. Ward, Arp, & Klotz (2011) stated that reduced
nitrogen molecules, primarily ammonia, are successively oxidized to nitrite and
nitrate through the microbial process known as nitrification. Drinking water
may contain ammonia due to naturally occurring activities or due to such
addition of ammonia throughout secondary disinfection that creates chloramines.
Two types of autotrophic nitrifying bacteria, which can create organic molecules
utilizing energy via inorganic sources like ammonia as well as nitrite, are
principally responsible for such a nitrification process Xiaohong, Juan, Lingli, Zhang, & Youbin (2021)
Hayatsu, Tago, Saito, & Nutrition (2008) mentioned that during the
first step of nitrification, ammonia-oxidizing bacteria AOB oxidize ammonia
into nitrite based on equation (1).
NH3 + O2 → NO2
- + 3H+ + 2e- (1)
Other genus, such
as Nitrosococcus and Nitrosospira,
have also been involved in this stage, Nitrosomonas
is the one that has been detected as one of the most frequent bacteria in this
stage. Some subgenera, including Nitrosolobus
and Nitrosovibrio, can indeed oxidise ammonia
autotrophically.
Through the
second step of the process, nitrite-oxidizing bacteria NOB oxidize nitrite into
nitrate based on equation (2).
NO2 -
+ H2O → NO3 - + 2H+ +2e-
(2)
The main method
for removing ammonia mostly from wastewater includes biological nitrifying
bacteria, which convert ammonia into nitrate through nitrite (Rani, Chowdhury, Tao, & Nedbalova, 2021)
Although slower
than autotrophic species, some heterotrophic bacterial and fungal groupings are
also capable of nitrification. According to nitrifying bacterial species found
within drinking water systems, the proportion of heterotrophic nitrifiers to
autotrophic nitrifiers may be very small. Contrarily, wastewater applications
experience heterotrophic nitrification. By transforming nitrate (NO3)
to gaseous nitrogen, the nitrogen component is released back into the air
atmosphere even during the denitrification process (N) (Zaidi & Sudthanom, 2011).
The soil-based Thiobacillus
species Clostridium & Pseudomonas bacteria carry out the
denitrification process when there is no oxygen present (Pan et al.2020). The
above process results in the generation of nitrous oxide (N2O) plus
nitrogen gas, which also are ultimately released into the atmosphere, from
nitrate compounds found in both soil and aquatic ecosystems. This process,
often known as the microbial process, involves a wide variety of microorganisms
(Einsle & Kroneck, 2004).
Nitrite → Nitric Oxide → Nitrous
oxide → Nitrogen gas.
The main
objectives of this research are to reduce harmful nitrogen forms from municipal wastewater and to investigate the fluctuation of AOB,
NOB, and Coliform bacterial communities during various steps of biological
nitrogen transformation (BNT) as ammonification, nitrification, and
denitrification processes from Zakho municipal wastewater in Iraq/Kurdistan Region.
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Description
of study area
This study was approved in Zakho City (ZC), which is located in the
Kurdistan Region of Iraq among both the latitudes of 37°22' and 37°14' N and
43°11' and 42°74' E and has an altitude of approximately 440m (Jindy et al. 2020).
One site that has
a direct release of domestic, industrial and also agricultural wastewater from
the point of water before reaching into the Khabor river in Zakho (Figure 1),
located at 37°08'47.0"N 42°41'46.0"E, was registered by the Global Positioning
System (GPS) program shown in Figure (2).
Figure 1.
Wastewater sample location area.
Figure 2.
Sample location in Zakho city/Iraq.
2.2 Sample
collection for biological nitrogen transforming and coliform during nitrogen
removal experiment.
In this study, a wastewater sample from the Zakho municipal sewage system
was collected, and eight clean plastic bottles of 20 L capacity were taken from
one site location (see Figure 1). The sample was
transported into the lab and put the wastewater sample in a container. Then
subjected to the treatment process of biological nitrogen transformation which
was subdivided into three stages ammonification, nitrification, and
denitrification in which three replicates of each stage were conducted in
container of 50L as shown in Figure (3).
Primary treatment was carried out individually by allowing the grit but
also sludge to settle mostly in the bottom of plastic containers. The upper
supernatant was therefore transferred to plastic pans of 50 L, and indeed the
secondary aerobic biological treatment was carried out by dissolved air flotation
(DAF) and putting an electrically powered water pump throughout the pans to
aerate the water and activate aerobic microbes to breakdown the organic waste
like proteins by biological nitrogen transformation (BNT) to ammonium by
ammonification, then this ammonium was converted to nitrite and nitrate through
two steps of nitrification process, two weeks period for ammonification, then
four weeks for nitrification . Then the water pump is released from the pans to
create an anaerobic condition in the pans to allow denitrifying bacteria for
another two weeks to convert this nitrate to the gaseous form of nitrous oxide
and dinitrogen gas to be liberated to the air. The AOB, NOB, and coliform bacteria were isolated and
enumerated to compare each steps of the process and
for confirmation, these steps were repeated three times by five replicates of
each specific culturing media, also the colour of and the smell of the water
changed during this process as shown in Figure (3).
Figure 3. Compare between two steps before ammonification (as control) and
after denitrification (final)
2.3
Isolation of Nitrifying bacteria (ammonium and nitrite oxidizing bacterial AOB
and NOB) strains from water sample
Throughout the process of both
isolating/quantifying selective bacteria, preceding cultures have been created
within an enriched and selective AOB and NOB medium through ammonium or through
nitrite and with bicarbonate as a source of carbon C, which might last for
hours or days, subsequently this type of bacteria grows very slowly because of
low energy produced in the process.
The composition of the liquid mineral medium
was consisted of; 0.1 g MgSO4 x 7H2O, 13.5 g Na2HPO4,
0.7 g KH2PO4, 0.01 g anhydrous FeCl3, 0.18 g
CaCl2 x 2H2O, 0.5 g (NH4)2SO4
and 0.5 g NaHCO3 for the ammonium oxidizing bacteria AOB. For the
nitrite-oxidizing bacteria NOB ammonium sulfate was
replaced with 0.5 g of NaNO2. The whole components were dissolved in
1L of distilled water. The final pH was measured by Model HI9024, HANNA
Instrument, which have been calibrated by pH 10.0,7.0, plus 4.0 standard buffer
solutions and adjusted as required to 7.5. Then the solution was filtered and
followed by adjusting with filter paper into two sterile containers (RodríguezRodríguez, MauInchaustegui,
PiedraCastro, JiménezMontealegre, & HerreraVargas, 2017).
Later on, a solid medium was prepared by
adding Agar-Agar (15g 1L) into distilled water and autoclaved at 1210C
for 20 minutes and stored at 4 0C for further analysis. Both
solutions-AOB and NOB-were diluted 2:1 with distilled water. To emphasize the
sterility of the solid medium, Agar-Agar plate was incubated over night at 280C.
0.5 ml of the diluted AOB, then it was transferred and separated onto the
incubated Agar-Agar plate and 0.2 ml of NOB and analysed in the same way as
shown above. Both plates which were incubated at 28oC for a week
grown colonies were between 25-250 CFU. Identification
and counting of natural nitrifying bacteria: the growth of the bacteria
colonies was observed on the inoculated plates in this study where liquid
mineral solutions were incubated at 280C. As this study shows, these techniques are
generally time-consuming and also eliminate a portion of the actual nitrifying
bacteria species through the process. However, during the process the technique
of the counting-plate was used. Furthermore, the amount of 468 CFU/ml of water
sample for AOB, and 2130 CFU/ml of water sample for NOB were counted Figure (4).
Figure 4. Plates of
AOB and NOB.
3. RESULT AND DISCUSSION
3.1 Removal
of harmful nitrogen forms.
The total Kjeldahl nitrogen is the most
important to be eliminated from the rest of harmful nitrogen forms comes from
this form. As indicated in Table (1), the total Kjeldahl
nitrogen was reduced by ammonification significantly through a period of 2
weeks as a considerable amount of organic nitrogen converted to ammonia when it
is activated by oxygen flotation in this stage. When aerobic condition is
continued for another month, the nitrifying bacteria are able to convert the
majority of total Kjeldahl nitrogen to nitrate. In the absence of oxygen in anaerobic
conditions for another two weeks, the denitrifying bacteria are able to convert
this nitrate to the gaseous form of nitrogen and to remove almost total
Kjeldahl nitrogen from the wastewater (Yamashita & Yamamoto 2014). Table (1) shows that at the end of denitrifying
process nearly half the of nitrite is converted to nitrate. Total nitrogen
which includes all organic and inorganic forms of nitrogen in wastewater is
significantly removed by BNT steps.
Table 1. Statistical description of
nitrogen forms removal from wastewater.
Nitrogen
Forms |
Mean |
± Std. Error |
Sig. |
|
|
||||
Total Kjeldahl Nitrogen TKN mg/l |
Control |
120.00 a |
.577 |
** |
Ammonification |
94.00 b |
.577 |
||
Nitrification |
25.00 c |
.577 |
||
Denitrification |
15.00 d |
.577 |
||
Ammonium
Nitrogen AN mg/l |
Control |
6.600 a |
.0577 |
** |
Ammonification |
7.200 a |
.0577 |
||
Nitrification |
5.500 b |
.0577 |
||
Denitrification |
4.000 c |
.5774 |
||
Total
Nitrogen TN mg/l |
Control |
140.0 a |
.577 |
** |
Ammonification |
117.0 b |
.577 |
||
Nitrification |
37.0 c |
.577 |
||
Denitrification |
10.0 d |
.577 |
||
Nitrate
Nitrogen NO3-N |
Control |
16.00 c |
.577 |
** |
Ammonification |
18.00 b |
.577 |
||
Nitrification |
29.00 a |
.577 |
||
Denitrification |
4.00 d |
.577 |
||
Nitrite
Nitrogen NO2-N |
Control |
.140 b |
.0057 |
** |
Ammonification |
.0830 c |
.0005 |
||
Nitrification |
2.00 a |
.5773 |
||
Denitrification |
.006 d |
.0005 |
||
Organic
Nitrogen ON |
Control |
112.00 a |
.577 |
** |
Ammonification |
85.00 b |
.577 |
||
Nitrification |
40.00 c |
.577 |
||
Denitrification |
21.00 d |
.577 |
Table (1) revealed that approximately
total nitrogen is removed from waste water, (Rajpal et al., 2021) the total-N was removed around 90%.
As indicated in Table (1), the BNT is efficient in
removing all forms of nitrogen from waste water, especially in the end of
denitrification process, nitrite reduced about 96% and nitrate reduced to 75%.
The organic form of nitrogen in wastewater is the source of continual water
pollution by ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate, methane, hydrogen sulfide, and nitrous oxide because it undergoes continual
degradation with the time by aerobic and anaerobic microbial respiration. A
part of organic nitrogen frequently remains with discharged water even after
different methods of treatment as some sorts of organic compounds are hard for
degradation and need relative long time. Around 71–87%, 81–93% plus
65–79% of removal amounts for TN, NO3-N and NH4-N loads from sewage water
treated reported by Asghari, Bochmann, & Tabari (2022)
As shown in Table (1), different BNT processes were
able to reduce organic nitrogen by ammonification, nitrification, and
denitrification to a large extend. Also Nourmohammadi
(2013) found that the NH4-N concentration decreased from
26.8 mg/L to 0.29 mg/L after biological treatment, and NO3-N
concentration increased from 8.8 mg/L to 27 mg/L after
nitrification process.
3.2 Nitrifying
and Pathogenic Bacteria
For Nitrosomonas
sp. and Nitrobacter sp., the shortest times for creation or division
discovered in a lab were between seven and ten hours, respectively as reported
by Spieck &
Bock (2005). However, in
natural environments, the majority of known nitrifying bacteria take several
days even weeks to complete a similar process, mainly depending just on
substrate type, the quantity of oxygen present in the water or soil,
temperature, and pH (Spieck &
Bock, 2005; Werner & Newton, 2005). Similarly, these bacteria may be affected by
the medium composition plus incubation conditions; therefore, it is possible
that only some portion of the nitrifying population is considered when
quantifying them. Almost every micro-organism has unique physiological,
metabolic, as well as morphological traits that set it apart from species
within the same genus, from many other genera, as well as from strains within
the same species. They might also share traits with one another that serve an evolutionary
purpose by giving them the variations and capacities they need to survive in
their environment or perhaps to adapt to all of it (Madigan,
Martinko, & Parker, 2003). The concentration range of DO in the medium
is one of the important factors for the nitrifying process dynamics; the
required concentration of oxygen of at least 2 mg/L must be present for the nitrifying
method to be successful (Constantine,
2008).
Isolation and
counting of pathogenic bacteria (total coliform bacteria) have done during the study
by using Mac-Conkey agar, and the number of colonies
decreased significantly which means that BNT process can also treat or decrease
the water from pathogenic bacteria Figure (5). Therefore, coliform bacteria
before ammonification have higher amount according to other steps it was 556
CFU/ml, after ammonification 226 CFU/ml, after nitrification 154 CFU/ml and after
denitrification 45 CFU/ml.
Figure 5. The
growth of total coliform bacteria on Mac-Conkey. 1.
Before ammonification, 2. After ammonification, 3. After nitrification and 4.
After denitrification.
Then gram staining is
applied to each of them, gram staining is one of the most used and important
techniques used by microbiologists. After applying the stains, the pink color appeared under the microscope because of the
gram-negative bacteria as shown in Figure (6).
Figure 6. Gram-negative bacteria (total
coliform) under microscope.
4. CONCLUSION
As the total amounts of harmful
nitrogen forms are significantly removed from the wastewater. The nitrogen
removal from wastewater by Biological Nitrogen Transformation (BNT) via
ammonification, nitrification, and denitrification is an effective, economic,
and eco-friendly method. The BNT was achieved firstly through the action of
microorganisms (bacteria). Firstly, the ammonification process converts reduced
organic nitrogen (R–NH2) to reduced inorganic nitrogen (ammonium NH4+).
Secondly, the nitrification process, which is aerobic, involves converting
ammonium in wastewater into nitrates. Two types of bacteria are responsible for
nitrification: Nitrosomonas and Nitrobacter. Finally, the
denitrification process converts nitrate to nitrogen through an anaerobic
process. So, further investigation on large scale about this process is needed
for wastewater treatments. The study concluded that the number of pathogenic
bacteria was also significantly reduced by BNT, but still need sterilization
agent as chlorination or ozonation to completely lethal this harmful bacterium.
A further study should be conducted on municipal wastewater to analyze
soil and sediments that were affected by pollutants. A storm water outlet
remediation device should be designed with the purpose of decreasing discharges
into Khabor River and efficiently removing dissolved toxic elements by using
various filters and absorbents. Furthermore, the study recommends applying and
using these procedures before discharging the wastewater into Khabor River.
REFERENCES
Asghari,
H. R., Bochmann, G., & Tabari, Z. T. J. S. (2022). Effectiveness of Biochar
and Zeolite Soil Amendments in Reducing Pollution of Municipal Wastewater from
Nitrogen and Coliforms. 14(14), 8880.
Amoatey, P. and R. Bani, Wastewater Management. 2011.
Constantine, T. J. C. C. M. H. (2008). An overview
of Ammonia and Nitrogen removal in wastewater treatment.
Crini, G., & Lichtfouse, E. J. E. C. L. (2019).
Advantages and disadvantages of techniques used for wastewater treatment. 17(1), 145-155.
Einsle, O., & Kroneck, P. M. (2004). Structural
basis of denitrification.
Hayatsu, M., Tago, K., Saito, M. J. S. S., &
Nutrition, P. (2008). Various players in the nitrogen cycle: diversity and
functions of the microorganisms involved in nitrification and denitrification. 54(1), 33-45.
Jindy, J. M., A. K. Qasim and S. A. J. S. J. o. U.
o. Z. Mohamad (2020). "Evaluation of Soil Pollution by Some Heavy Metals
Via Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometer (AAS) Technique in Zakho District,
Kurdistan Region-Iraq." 8(4):
145-148.
Madigan, M. T., Martinko, J., & Parker, J. J. E.
P. P. H. I., Madrid. Pp. (2003). Brock. Biología de los microorganismos 12 ed. 1064.
Mittal, A. J. W. T. (2011). Biological wastewater
treatment. 1, 32-44.
Pan, Z., et al., Effects of COD/TN ratio on nitrogen removal
efficiency, microbial community for high saline wastewater treatment based on
heterotrophic nitrification-aerobic denitrification process. 2020. 301: p.
122726.
Rajpal, A., Srivastava, G., Bhatia, A., Singh, J.,
Ukai, Y., Kazmi, A. A. J. E. T., & Innovation. (2021). Optimization to
maximize nitrogen removal and microbial diversity in PVA-gel based process for
treatment of municipal wastewater. 21,
101314.
Rani, S., Chowdhury, R., Tao, W., & Nedbalova,
L. J. S. (2021). Microalga-Mediated Tertiary Treatment of Municipal Wastewater:
Removal of Nutrients and Pathogens. 13(17),
9554.
RodríguezRodríguez, A., MauInchaustegui, S.,
PiedraCastro, L., JiménezMontealegre, R., & HerreraVargas, J. J. R. d. B.
T. (2017). Isolation of ammonium-and nitrite-oxidizing bacterial strains from
soil, and their potential use in the reduction of nitrogen in household waste
water. 65(4), 1527-1539.
Ruas, G., Serejo, M., Farias, S., Scarcelli, P.,
Boncz, M. J. I. J. o. E. S., & Technology. (2022). Removal of pathogens
from domestic wastewater by microalgal-bacterial systems under different
cultivation conditions. 19(10), 10177-10188.
Robertson, G. P. and P. M. Groffman (2007). Nitrogen
transformations. Soil microbiology, ecology and biochemistry, Elsevier:
341-364.
Spieck, E., & Bock, E. J. T. l. n.-o. b. B. s.
M. o. S. B. (2005). The Proteobacteria, Part Introductory Essays. 149-153.
Strock, J. (2008). Ammonification. In Encyclopedia of ecology, five-volume set
(pp. 162-165): Elsevier Inc.
Templeton, M. R., & Butler, D. (2011). Introduction to wastewater treatment:
Bookboon.
Wang, J., Chen, Y., Cai, P., Gao, Q., Zhong, H.,
Sun, W., & Chen, Q. J. J. o. H. M. (2022). Impacts of municipal wastewater
treatment plant discharge on microbial community structure and function of the
receiving river in Northwest Tibetan Plateau. 423, 127170.
Ward, B. B., Arp, D. J., & Klotz, M. G. (2011). Nitrification: American Society for
Microbiology Press.
Werner, D., & Newton, W. E. (2005). Nitrogen fixation in agriculture, forestry,
ecology, and the environment (Vol. 4): Springer Science & Business
Media.
Xiaohong, L., Juan, W., Lingli, W., Zhang, L., &
Youbin, S. J. P. (2021). Impacts of silver nanoparticles on enzymatic
activities, nitrifying bacteria, and nitrogen transformation in soil amended
with ammonium and nitrate. 31(6),
934-943.
Zaidi, S. F. A., & Sudthanom, J. (2011). To Analyze
The Relationship between BOD, Nitrogen And Phosphorus Contents at Constant
Dissolved Oxygen Concentration In Municipal Wastewater Treatment. In.